Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
45 to 50 People Lunch
35 to 40 People Lunch
45 to 50 People Breakfast
35 to 40 People Breakfast
About
Bagel Street
Welcome to Bagel Street, a delightful little haven nestled at 437 Park Ave S, New York, NY 10016. This local gem has quickly made a name for itself among bagel aficionados and casual diners alike, drawing rave reviews for its fresh and flavorful offerings. Whether you're grabbing your morning coffee or looking for a satisfying lunch, Bagel Street promises an experience that delights the palate.
At Bagel Street, the star of the show is undeniably the bagels. With a variety of cream cheese spreads, including the standout jalapeno cream cheese with eggplant and veggies and the rich avocado cream cheese, there’s something for everyone. One customer fondly referred to this combo as “one of my favorite bagels I have ever had,” a testament to the quality and creativity that Bagel Street brings to its menu.
The bagel sandwiches are a must-try as well. Diners have praised the pastrami egg and cheese on an everything bagel with added avocado as one of the best bagel sandwiches they've encountered in NYC. The perfect balance of flavors, combined with soft yet chewy bagels, creates a culinary experience that feels both comforting and indulgent. And with reasonable prices, it's an affordable option in a city known for its inflated dining costs.
Some highlights of the menu include:
- Egg White Specials: Such as the Three Egg Whites with avocado and sautéed spinach, perfect for a healthy start to your day.
- Chicken Sandwiches: Try the Chicken Club Sandwich, loaded with crispy bacon and melted cheese for a decadent treat.
- Muffins and Pastries: Sweet tooth? The strawberry and chocolate croissants will satisfy any craving.
But it’s not just the food that keeps customers coming back; it’s also the inviting atmosphere and exemplary service. As one repeat patron noted, “The nicest people and the best bagel sandwiches in the city!” Even during busy hours, the staff at Bagel Street manages to provide swift service, making it a convenient stop for those on the go.
With a simple decor that encourages relaxation, Bagel Street allows guests to enjoy their meal in peace. Here, every visit can feel like discovering a hidden treasure in NYC—a community spot where the food is consistently good and the ambiance warm. So, next time you find yourself in New York, make sure to stop by Bagel Street. Your taste buds will thank you!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ I got jalapeno cream Cheese with eggplant and veggies and got avocado cream cheese with everything bagel absolutely one of my favorite bagels I have ever had . Place is awesome so many awesome choices of meats bagels cheese veggies its definitely a place where I can go and find something to eat definitely will visit again if I m in Newyork thank you for servicing amazing food loved it all also saved some For after to eat on our way back to Toronto ”
“ Definitely the best bagel sandwich Ive had in NY! I got the pastrimi egg and cheese on an everything bagel with avocado added to it. Bagel was great, pastrimi was so tasty, and overall 1010 sandwich. Wasnt too crowded on a Sunday during brunch hours so definitely a hidden gem in my opinion. ”
“ This place is a hidden gem. Not crowded at all and the bagels were delicious! It was also very affordable for NYC! ”
“ Nicest people and the best bagel sandwiches in the city!! The food is always consistent and the service is super fast even when its busy. We love this place. ”
“ Simple decor but simply excellent bagels got the BLT with avocado and cream cheese on plain toasted. Tried the same elsewhere and bagel street was superior. Coffee too hot for even my Teflon mouth just need time to let it cool. ”
“ I LOVE their bagels ! Top it with either the pastrami or bacon. Add eggs, cheese, whatever, its always tasting good and fresh. I personally also like their omelets hearty portions. They are super fast and friendly, unlike many similar establishments in the city. They open early, but sadly close at 4pm, so better get there by 230p3p. AH, and one more thing it looks super clean in there good prices I know! ”
“ If youre wandering down Park Avenue with a bagel craving, Bagel Street is the place to stop. Our recent visit there was a delightful culinary journey. I tried the Lox on an everything bagel, and while the bagel itself was a tad dense for my taste, the lox was seasoned to perfection. The cream cheese jelly on a toasted bagel, however, was absolutely spot on it had the perfect balance of flavors and textures, encapsulating everything you could wish for in a bagel. Additionally, the customer service was commendable the staff were welcoming and efficient. ”
“ 2404 Lovely Pumpernickel. Aromatic, dense, dark. Beautiful crunchy crust. Tofu cream cheese tastes good too and complements the bagels nutty slightly sourdoughy taste. Wholewheat is too white. I thought it was plain and can only see small bits of grain. Its on the softer and fluffier side and has no crust almost a tearapart bread roll but still chewy enough to be considered a bagel. Ill probably skip this one. Egg white and spinach and cheese and mushroom filling tastes really good. I was worried when my friend who recommended it said the bagel here tastes like mochi, but its not that squishy ”